Critique!

During my writing class we get to submit one piece for the class to critique. Yikes! My piece was critiqued tonight.  Its an expanded version (draft 2) of the Genderqueer Undearthed piece I wrote back in March.  Besides wanting to flesh out that piece some more, my understanding of myself has changed (and will continue to evolve) so some of the passages in the original piece are no longer true.

 I got a lot of really helpful feedback and Im going to keep working on this.  Its hard for me to share work that I think is still in progress, I think especially this one as it chronicles a lifetime of denial/self acceptance and some really difficult moments. Im glad I can look back from a place of confidence and put humor around things that were not at all funny for me at the time.  So without further adieu...

A Bender on Gender

"Can you call my grandfather? He could come pick me up."  The school nurse had caved yet again and was letting me go home. In the 6^th grade I developed a habit of faking sick. Usually the ailments were embarrassment or boredom, manifesting as a mysterious, incurable pain in my stomach. I don’t remember why I was at the nurse's office this time.  Maybe it was that day in sex ed when the teacher claimed some girls have more testosterone than "normal."

“These girls might have lower voices,” she explained, provoking a lot of snickers and pointed fingers in my direction.

I began to wonder if the permission slip my parents signed allowing me to participate in sex ed was really more like a waiver for skydiving. Grandpa pulled up in the Cadillac. Tan. My grandmother's was canary yellow, which he referred to as “the junker.” The smells of leather and Old Spice greeted me as I slid across the passenger’s seat. Trying to keep up my sick act, I attempted to suppress the relief I felt and focus on the guilt of dishonestly cutting school.

Bullshit was Grandpa's native language so of course he knew I was full of it.  He played along and we made some small talk on the way home. Grandpa had just got a puppy named Max. Max was a wild Collie, tearing through the apple orchard after deer and peeing all over the kitchen floor. He seemed entirely nonplussed to be beaten with a newspaper while chewing on Grandma's rattan furniture in the sunroom.

“Max doesn’t seem all that obedient,” I commented.

"Well," Grandpa replied, “that’s because Max isn’t old enough to understand English."  I nodded knowingly while wondering if dogs really ever understood English. Grandpa smirked his wry smile, the same smile I smirk when someone believes a total bullshit story I tell them.

Born an androgynous female in rural America in the 80s, gender is a concept I could have done without. From the get go I wanted to be a boy.  I dressed like a boy. I carried myself like a boy. I played exclusively with boys, tackling, fighting, spitting.  I was confused when my dad wouldn’t let me take my shirt off to play basketball. I wanted very, very badly to be a Boy Scout. More than anything I remember wanting to be my grandfather. He was always so put together; I remember him in brown slacks and a striped oxford and a tie with a gold chain tethering the tie to his shirt. He didn’t speak much, but had this way of making you believe anything he said.

“Is that a boy or a girl? I think it’s a boy.”

I sat on the ground nursing my elbow. I’d just tried riding my boyfriend's skateboard. Turns out a maiden skateboard voyage down a steep sidewalk isn’t the brightest idea. Both my elbow and my ego were smarting as the kids across the street mulled over what I was. I pulled down my ball cap and walked around the back of the house.

While I was just being myself my childhood peers were noticing that I wasn’t the same as they were. I think at some point my parents uncomfortably realized it wasn’t a "tomboy phase" that was going to go away.  I was a lone queer in a small town. By the time I met other queer people I had no idea that I was one of them. I was convinced that something was wrong with me. I was too aggressive, wore the wrong clothes and had the tiniest breasts of anyone I knew. And dating? I understood as much about dating as Max the dog did about English. I never had feelings for the boys I dated. I just assumed it was some kind of defect, just like my masculine traits. 

Growing up we had one of those big console TVs. It resided in a stunning fake wood enclosure which attempted to legitimize its place among the living room furniture. To change channels you had to get up and manually turn the dial. 44 was PBS. 38 was FOX (best after school cartoons). 16 was WNEP Newswatch 16. The rest was white noise. If you tuned the dial to a setting just before a channel you could faintly make out the image and garbled audio in the white noise. I felt like one of those phantom channels; something was there, but it wasn’t quite in focus. I tried to modify my behavior, my clothes. I tried religion, graduate school, getting married to a man and extreme sports. In hindsight I was kind of like Max the dog, tearing around spending my nervous energy in an attempt to flee my pain. The whole time it never felt right.

“No matter what someone says, it’s never about you. It is always about them.”

Shifting listlessly in a metal folding chair I found myself in some hippie group of people trying to learn to communicate better. I wasn’t a hippie, but I was a soon-to-be-divorced terrified 28 yr. old running around (again) this time trying to salvage a relationship that had long been dead. We drank tea and talked about our feelings. Eventually I got over being jaded about west coast new age woo woo and learned some things. Like how to empathize with myself, and that the things others tell us really have nothing to do with us. Really!

Suddenly, I realized I’d spent my life blaming myself for who I was and I resolved to face it.

In a truly meditative fashion I began unearthing myself. Meditating goes like this: you resolve to sit still for some time, usually longer than you’ve sat still in a long while, maybe ever, and attempt to “clear your mind.” What actually happens is you get about 30 seconds into your “om” chanting and someone lets Max out and he chases deer all over the orchard like a maniac. After some time you realize what is going on, lock Max back up, and then repeat. Occasionally you scratch your ear and wonder if that’s OK.

Om - “I’ve always wanted to live in Northwest Portland. I’m going to move there!”

Max- “I'm going to work out like a maniac, climb Mt Hood and do a triathlon!”

That’s kind of intense. How about we pick one sport? Cycling. That’s a nice sport.

Om - “Cycling is great. I like riding with these nice people on country roads and having a beer.”

Max - “I’m going to race bikes! Ill join a team and train 10hrs a week in the pouring rain because I’m that hardcore. I’m also going to take hot yoga, because that is also hardcore.

Annnnd now I’m injured. Guess I’ll just stick to yoga for now.

Om – Wow. I really feel amazing around my yoga teacher Cindy. It’s like all the feelings I expected to have with men but...

Max – I shall learn the lyrics to every Indigo Girls song! I’ll hang out with softball players and go to Pride.

Why is nothing happening? Clearly this was a dumb idea.

Om – I don't enjoy my job. In fact, I think what attracted me to this field is that it is so mentally demanding I don't have time to think about my life. I’m going to figure out what I’d really like to do.

Max – While changing careers I’m going to train to ride my bike on the world's steepest, longest mountains in Northern Italy! While I’m grinding up glaciated peaks Ill chew on rattan.

And so it went. I started coming into focus on this rollercoaster ride. My family started noticing that my witty quips and wry smile were coming back. I wore dresses and makeup and grew my hair, then I chopped it all off, bought a men’s suit and started lifting weights. Finally things were feeling right. As it turns out I wasn’t too off base with the yoga teacher and to my delighted surprise I am quite a charming fellow. I feel like a mixture of Rainbow Brite and HeMan, soaring through the sky on the back of Falcor.

As a child, faced with the compartmentalization of "boy things" and "girl things" I definitely wanted to be a boy. What I’ve realized is really, I just wanted to be myself and forget about all this gender nonsense. Sometimes that means I want to crochet or wear makeup. Other times that means I want to be a quick witted, dapper gentleman, smiling wryly as I try to convince a pretty lady that at a certain age, dogs understand English.